Deciding on a the “RAW” Colorspace for Lightroom 4 and ACR 7 vs. Aperture 3

You’re concerned your choice of Post Processing software will affect your final product’s colors. You want to protect you RAW files from the evils and unknowns of color space choices.

Bottom line up front

Don’t choose between Lightroom or Aperture based on how they handle you’re image’s color. If getting the print’s color the way you want it matters enough to you then calibrate your monitor.

Post Processing – the choices

Lightroom 4

  • It’s Color Space is Pro Photo
  • It has Soft Proofing ( this can show you what colors won’t be supported in various export scenarios )

Aperture 3

  • Uses an unnamed Apple proprietary color space

If this scares you then you didn’t read the intro or the Conclusion.

RAW

The type of file made by your camera when it does no post processing and no color space choosing itself. It’s RAW. It’s just the digital representation of the light your sensor recorded. It doesn’t have color or anything. Once you do anything to it, it’s not RAW anymore. that means it’s on its first step to some type of export. Until you hit the export button though, you still get to benefit from a lot of RAW’s information.

  • Canon uses .CR2, Nikon uses .NEF
  • RAW has more color than any color space
  • This includes light and dark colors. This means you get more details in light a dark areas.
  • These light and dark area details are not noticeable on any monitor or print because no color space has the same number of crayons as RAW.

Color space

The number and color of crayons in a crayon box. It’s also called Gamut. The colors in a RAW file are not lost until the image is exported. Because of this here is where  color spaces matter;

  • Monitors (calibrate to printer)
  • Print Labs (know it’s color space and calibration settings)
  • Printer (same)
  • Camera (if shooting Jpeg choose a colorspace)
  • Export settings (set to match printer/printshop’s colorspace)

Here are where the color spaces you shouldn’t care about;

  • Post processing software  acting as a Digital Asset Manager (just cataloging RAWs)

Until you export your image you don’t lose any crayons. The moment you do you have to leave some behind.

Print colors

The amount of range in colors when printing is decided by your export color space choice. The more crayons the more information being sent to the printer.

  • Consistency between your edit and your print is only dependent on you monitor being calibrated to the printer. If you use a print shop you can get their profiles and then calibrate it from there.
  • You can’t calibrate your post processing software

Conclusion

Don’t choose Lightroom over Aperture because it protects your RAW images better. This is a misnomer. Once your monitor is calibrated, what you edit for on LR or Aperture is what you’ll get on the print.

Photoshop round trip side note

The roundtrip from Lightroom to Photoshop and the roundtrip between Aperture and Photoshop are equally easy to do. Opening the photo up in Photoshop from your native program is easy. Make changes, hit save and viola its a new version is visible in your native application.

There is one issue. Sending it to Photoshop from Aperture or Lightroom is actually exporting the file to Photoshop you are buying into a color space for the image. To help these programs play the best here are some screen capture of setting I recommend.

Screen Shot 2013-02-03 at 10.51.40 PM

Lightroom 4 screenshot for Photoshop colorspace Workflow

Screen Shot 2013-02-03 at 10.46.42 PM

Aperture 3 screenshot for Photoshop colorspace workflow

Screen Shot 2013-02-03 at 10.47.27 PM

Import setting for colorspace for Photoshop 6

Related

This article addresses Aperture Color Space workflow in more detail.

About these ads

2 comments

  1. [...] You’re concerned your choice of Post Processing software will affect your final product’s colors. You want to protect you RAW files from the evils and unknowns of color space choices. Bottom line u…  [...]

    Like

  2. [...] Users perceive an advantage for Lightroom for Photoshop centric workflow and/or RAW processing [...]

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 1,023 other followers

%d bloggers like this: